Skip to content
srinivasBJ

Unknown Liquid: My Thought Experiment on What Could Be Fundamental

A personal thought experiment exploring the idea of an “Unknown Liquid” as a conceptual unstable matter system. The model questions whether reality could emerge from a deeper phase-changing medium rather than empty space, using analogies from fluid transitions, instability, and state-dependent physical behavior. It reflects on whether Big Bang expansion could be interpreted as a phase transition inside an underlying dynamic system rather than a singular explosion.

4 min read

1. What I was actually wondering (introduction)

I started thinking something simple but confusing.

Everything we see—solid, liquid, gas—keeps changing form. Water becomes vapor, vapor becomes liquid again. Nothing really “disappears”; it just changes shape.

So I asked myself:

If everything is just changing form, then what is the original form?

Then I started wondering if the Big Bang itself could have come from something that is not empty space, but something like a “liquid-like medium” that already existed in some form.

Not normal water — something unknown, something fundamental.


2. Why I thought about “liquid” in the first place

Because liquids feel like they are “in-between states”.

  • Solid → rigid
  • Gas → fully free
  • Liquid → in-between, flexible, adaptive

So I thought:

What if the universe itself started from this “in-between state”?

Not a solid object. Not empty space. But something that can change form.


3. Where my confusion started (important part)

Then I started questioning:

If something like this exists, then why don’t we see it directly?

Because in normal life:

  • Distilled water is “pure”
  • But it does not create anything new by itself
  • Impurities (ions, particles) change behavior

So I thought:

Maybe “creation” needs some kind of internal structure or “activity” inside the medium.

That led me to imagine:

What if the early universe was not empty, but had some kind of active medium already inside it?

Not just passive matter — but something that reacts, collapses, or expands.


4. Mathematical / Computational Model (Conceptual)

Let the Unknown Liquid be represented as a dynamic non-equilibrium field system, where physical properties are not constants but emergent functions of internal state and external conditions.


4.1 Dynamic Viscosity Function

V(t,p,T,σ)=f(θ(t))V(t, p, T, \sigma) = f(\theta(t))

Where:

  • tt = time evolution parameter
  • pp = pressure
  • TT = temperature
  • σ\sigma = applied external stress
  • θ(t)\theta(t) = internal latent state variable governing microscopic configuration

👉 Interpretation:
Viscosity is not fixed; it is controlled by an internal evolving state rather than only external thermodynamic conditions.


4.2 State Transition Probability Model

P(SiSj)=eΔEij/kTZ+ϵP(S_i \rightarrow S_j) = \frac{e^{-\Delta E_{ij} / kT}}{Z + \epsilon}

Where:

  • Si,SjS_i, S_j = discrete material states
  • ΔEij\Delta E_{ij} = energy barrier between states
  • kTkT = thermal energy scale
  • ZZ = normalization (partition function)
  • ϵ\epsilon = instability perturbation term

👉 Interpretation:
State transitions follow thermodynamic probability, but include an instability term ϵ\epsilon that introduces deviation from classical equilibrium behavior.


4.3 Instability Threshold Function

Φ(p,T,σ)>Φcstate collapse or transition\Phi(p, T, \sigma) > \Phi_c \Rightarrow \text{state collapse or transition}

Where:

  • Φ(p,T,σ)\Phi(p, T, \sigma) = combined instability field
  • Φc\Phi_c = critical threshold

👉 Interpretation:
When environmental stress crosses a critical boundary, the system does not change gradually — it undergoes abrupt phase transition or collapse.


5. My working idea (simplified model)

So I started imagining a model:

Unknown Liquid (concept idea)

Not a real liquid, but a system where:

  • state is not fixed (solid / liquid / gas all possible)
  • properties keep changing
  • small changes can create large effects

We can think like:

Viscosity idea (simple version)

Instead of constant viscosity:

V=V(time,pressure,internal state)V = V(\text{time}, \text{pressure}, \text{internal state})

Meaning:

  • it is not fixed
  • it depends on what is happening inside

6. The Big Bang connection I was trying to imagine

What if the Big Bang was not an explosion from nothing, but a transition inside such a system?

Like:

  • a sudden phase change
  • instability point
  • collapse → expansion

Not a liquid literally, but something that behaves like:

  • unstable medium
  • phase-changing system

7. Where I am unsure (honest part)

I don’t know if this is physically correct.

Because:

  • we don’t have evidence of such a medium
  • modern physics already uses fields, not liquids
  • many assumptions here are based on analogy, not measurement

But still, the idea feels like:

Maybe reality is not “objects moving in space”, but “states changing inside a deeper system”


8. Final understanding I reached

So my conclusion is not:

“Unknown liquid exists”

But instead:

Maybe what we call matter and universe expansion are different states of a deeper underlying system we still don’t fully understand.


Optional formula idea (very simple)

Instead of fixed physics:

state=f(environment,internal instability)\text{state} = f(\text{environment}, \text{internal instability})

or

universe=evolving system of phase transitions\text{universe} = \text{evolving system of phase transitions}

Suggested visualization

A medium that is not fully solid, not fully liquid, where tiny changes create large structural transformations over time.